I prefer Dr Dispatch's desk top software. Web Based systems are not secure at all.
It's easy to tell that you've stuck with a theme from your own experience that most 3PL's - who don't want or need a lot of bells and whistles - can genuinely appreciate:
keeping the software as familiar as possible, so a user can actually concentrate on moving freight.
As someone who's done everything from driven the truck to managing the fleet, I can certainly tell you that Dr Dispatch deserves the highest praise for simplifying dispatchers jobs without forcing them to become software experts.